Most advice on heating your home sustainably starts with a specific technology – usually a heat pump – and works backwards from there. That’s the wrong order. Which low-carbon heating option actually makes sense for your home depends first on how well that home holds onto heat, and only then on which system you install. Skip that step, and even the right technology can end up costing you more, not less.

Swapping a gas boiler for a heat pump doesn’t automatically cut your bills or your carbon footprint – it depends entirely on how much heat your home loses in the first place. A heat pump run in a poorly insulated, draughty building has to work far harder to reach the same temperature, and that extra electricity use can outweigh any efficiency gain.

Modelling showed installing an air source heat pump on this Bristol health centre as it stood would have increased annual running costs by around £6,000 – the building’s fabric was too poor for the heat pump to run efficiently. Fixing the insulation and airtightness first, then adding the heat pump, was projected to take the building from an EPC E (106) to an A (20).

That’s the pattern that shows up across genuinely evidenced retrofit projects: insulation and airtightness improvements come first, and the heating system upgrade follows once the fabric can actually support it.

Before any heating system enters the picture, it’s worth addressing the three things that determine how much heat a building loses in the first place:

Treated together, these three measures are usually the most cost-effective way to reduce a home’s energy demand – before deciding which heating technology should meet whatever demand is left.

Air source heat pumps (ASHPs) are currently the default low-carbon heating technology for most UK homes, extracting heat from outside air rather than burning fuel to generate it. They typically run most efficiently at lower flow temperatures than a gas boiler, which is why they’re often paired with underfloor heating or appropriately sized radiators rather than a home’s existing (smaller) radiators. Done well, ASHPs are a genuinely effective part of a wider energy strategy – but as above, they perform best once a home’s fabric is ready to support them.

Across 8 representative Somerset properties, fabric measures alone typically moved homes from EPC D or C into the C/B range – but pairing insulation improvements with an air source heat pump and solar PV took several homes to an EPC A rating, cutting regulated carbon emissions by up to 89%.

For a deeper look at how ASHPs actually work and whether your specific home is ready for one, see our companion guides:

On new-build and larger retrofit projects, a heat pump paired with solar PV (Energy Saving Trust Solar Panel Guidance) is often the strategy that clears a stricter carbon reduction target, rather than either measure alone.

To exceed South Gloucestershire’s Policy PSP6 requirement for a 20% carbon reduction, this new-build development combined high-performance fabric (external walls at 0.18 W/m²K, well ahead of Part L minimums) with a fully electric strategy – air source heat pumps for heating and hot water, paired with a solar PV array sized across the site.

For denser housing – terraces, flats or a cluster of neighbouring properties – connecting to or forming a shared heat network (DESNZ Heat Networks Guidance) can be a more cost-effective route than installing individual heat pumps property by property.

Comparing a community-owned secondary heat network connection against individual air source heat pumps for a 14-property Bedminster portfolio, the community route came in at roughly a third of the capital cost per dwelling.

This won’t apply to every home – it depends on proximity to an existing or planned network, and on enough neighbouring properties being willing to participate – but where it’s viable, it’s worth assessing before committing to individual systems.

Alongside fabric and heating, a handful of smaller measures add up:

None of these replace fixing fabric and heating first, but they’re straightforward, low-cost additions once the bigger measures are in hand.

The honest answer is that it depends on your specific building, and guessing is how homes end up with a heat pump working harder than it should, or fabric measures that were never actually the priority. Your home’s Energy Performance Certificate (EPC Register) is a starting point – if you don’t already have one, a Domestic Energy Assessor can produce one, and it’s required if you plan to sell or rent the property. Beyond that, a proper assessment covering airtightness, insulation, ventilation and your current heating system together gives you a sequenced, evidenced plan rather than a single technology recommendation in isolation.

What’s Next?

Getting the sequence right – fabric first, then the right heating technology for your specific home – is what separates a genuine reduction in bills and carbon from a heating system working against the building it’s installed in.

Get in touch if you’d like to talk through the right sequence of measures for your own home.

Keep Informed

Get practical insights on retrofit, decarbonisation and compliance, delivered straight to your inbox.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.